NW Natural scraps plans for blended hydrogen and natural gas project in Eugene
A natural gas-burning plant in Hermiston would be the center of an emissions-reduction project to fight climate change. Pictured here, a worker checks gauges on a natural gas tank. (Getty Images)
Oregon’s first green hydrogen production project has been shelved after public pushback over potential environmental and health impacts.
NW Natural, the state’s largest natural gas provider, had proposed to the Oregon Public Utilities Commission in August a plan to create green hydrogen to blend into its natural gas. The company would have pumped the blended gas to 2,500 customers in west Eugene by early 2024.
It pitched the project as an experimental way to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions and to hone production of green hydrogen, which is made when electricity powered from renewable sources is run through water to separate oxygen and hydrogen. The hydrogen is trapped and blended into the natural gas, which is primarily methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
Environmental and social justice groups pushed back, saying the project had little emissions-reduction benefit. They also said NW Natural hadn’t undertaken an analysis of health and safety risks to customers who would burn the fuel in their homes, that the $10 million price tag was too costly and the company’s current customers across the state would be left holding the bill.
Among the six groups that intervened in the approvals process are the NAACP of Eugene-Springfield, Oregon Physicians for Social Responsibility and the Sierra Club.
NW Natural withdrew its proposal on Tuesday. In the filing to withdraw, NW Natural explained why it chose to scrap the proposal altogether rather than just suspend the approvals process for a few months while it solicited more community input.
“NW Natural is seeking to convey that it is willing to engage in stakeholder outreach without a predefined time limit that would have been included as part of a motion to suspend the procedural schedule, and that it is willing to consider changes to the project in light of such outreach,” NW Natural attorney Ryan Sigurdson wrote. The company had held two meetings with community members prior to August. The company could still file an application for the same project or a revised version of the project in the future, according to the filing.
Critics of the project were particularly concerned with where the blended natural gas would end up.
About 66% of the residents in one west Eugene neighborhood that would be receiving it are considered low-income, and its home to a larger share of people of color compared to the rest of Eugene, according to the coalition of environmental and social justice groups. Residents are already in an area that deals with high levels of air pollution from nearby factories and with higher rates of childhood asthma compared with the rest of the city, according to an analysis from the Eugene-based nonprofit Beyond Toxics.
When hydrogen is used in a fuel cell, such as for a car, it gives off no emissions, but when it is combusted for heat or for cooking it generates nitrogen oxide, which can cause respiratory issues, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
“Eugene residents will not be forced to be guinea pigs for experimental and dangerous technology that perpetrates fossil fuel infrastructure, environmental injustices and more air toxics,” Lisa Arkin, executive director of Beyond Toxics, said in a statement.
“This project was absolutely unacceptable, and its withdrawal is a testament to the power of community opposition.”
CORRECTION: The Bethel neighborhood is in the 90th percentile of low-income households per capita nationally, and 66% of households are low-income. A previous version this story said 90% of residents are low-income.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site.